Blessings to you, the readers of this page, in Jesus Christ our Lord. May He guide you and protect you always.

Supreme Court Case Little v. Barreme Proves That Laws Of Congress Always Outrank Inherent Executive Powers

Presidential Power Never Exceeds Congressional Power. Tail Does Not Wag The Dog

The President Has No Inherent Power To Violate FISA Or Any Other Law Duly Enacted By Congress, Even In Times Of War

The Supreme Court ruled directly on this subject in the early days of our Country, when the Founders' intentions were fresh and clear in people's minds. The case involved the President going against a duly-enacted Law of Congress, regarding a military action in a time of semi-declared war. And the Supreme Court ruled that the President's actions were illegal, because they violated this law enacted by Congress.

In the case "Little v. Barreme," in 1804 The Supreme Court ruled that a part of President John Adams' instructions to seize ships was in conflict with an act of Congress and therefore illegal. Congress had passed a law instructing the President to seize certain ships going to France. President Adams changed that to include certain ships that were either going to or coming from France. A ship was seized coming from France. So the seizure followed the Presidential instructions, but violated the Law passed by Congress, which only involved ships going to France. On appeal, the case came before the Supreme Court.

Chief Justice Marshall wrote, "On an appeal to the circuit court this sentence was reversed, because the Flying Fish was on a voyage from, not to, a French port, and was therefore, had she even been an American vessel, not liable to capture on the high seas."

And by writing this, Chief Justice Marshall provides us today with the answer to a question which was never even asked when the Founders wrote the Constitution, because it was obvious to everybody then that Acts of Congress were more authoritative than anything the President might want to do. Congress makes the laws, the President faithfully executes them. And if he fails to do so, Congress can remove him from office.

You can read this entire case at
LITTLE v. BARREME, 6 U.S. 170 (1804): http://laws.findlaw.com/us/6/170.html

One scholar described the case like this: "But Chief Justice Marshall wrote that even in his capacity as commander in chief, the president could not authorize a military officer to perform illegal acts. Only Congress can make laws, Marshall argued, and regardless of the fact that the president may have ordered his subordinate officer to perform an illegal act, that act was still illegal, and the officer performing that act was responsible for his behavior. Not even a military officer, Marshall wrote, could use the 'instruction of the executive' as an excuse for performing an illegal act."

Source: IMBALANCE OF POWERS - Constitutional Interpretation and the Making of American Foreign Policy, by Gordon Silverstein, New York Oxford OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS 1997

Blessings to you. May God help us all. And may God bless America!

Rev. Bill McGinnis, Director
http://www.Internet Church Of Christ - LoveAllPeople.org
and http://www.InternetchurchOfChrist.org

Blessings to you. May God help us all.

       Rev. Bill McGinnis, Director - LoveAllPeople.org

If you are looking for a spiritual home, please visit our website at => Internet Church Of Christ
*** Bible-Based, Christian, Progressive, Universalist ***

All of our original content on all of our web pages is in the Public Domain. You may link to these pages by any means you choose, including "framing."

Index of Internet Church Of Christ - LoveAllPeople.org: - ETHICS & HUMAN RELATIONS - POLITICS & PUBLIC AFFAIRS - CHRISTIAN - AUTOMOTIVE - LAW & LEGAL SERVICES - HEALTH & FITNESS - PUBLISHING & CONSULTING - AFFILIATES & FEATURED PRODUCTS - SITE MAP - CONTACT LINK

"Seeking The Greatest Good For The Greatest Number, With Basic Rights For All."
Search all pages in The LoveAllPeople.org Network,
using the search box below . . .

For list of suggested searches, click => HERE!

See what we do => On The Web


To support us, please visit the advertisers appearing on our pages.

We are . . . Internet Church Of Christ - LoveAllPeople.org - Teaching the practical Christian life.
"Treat Others As You Would Like To Be Treated."

You can follow Rev. Bill McGinnis on Twitter, at => http://www.twitter.com/revbillmcginnis

God's One Law For All Mankind: "Love All People As Yourself."